11/30/2023 0 Comments Pros and cons of a manuscript speechIt’s critical that a paper makes use of proper citations so pay close attention to references that might be missing and assure that references being made are current enough to still be relevant. Make sure the manuscript makes mention of any limitations in the scientific process and properly positions itself with respect to other studies, including the importance of this specific paper. Look for clarity from the discussion and conclusionĪuthors must interpret the results of their experiment in a way that considers previous findings and explains what their study means for the future of research in the field.Revisit a manuscript with specific consideration of statistical methods being used and if you don’t feel qualified to evaluate the reporting in the paper at hand, don’t be afraid to tell your editor so they can ask someone else to review this section. Have a solid understanding of statistics.Make sure that measures of uncertainty are defined and that data is not repeated within any explanations. With results being one of the sections a reader will read the most closely, it’s important that the information included in figures and tables can be understood outside the larger context of the paper. Examine results and figures with a sharp eye.Controls and comparators should be accurately defined and the means of analyzing the data as well as the outcome measures should be objectively validated. The overall quality of the paper is dependent on the study’s methods so look to be sure that the methods make it clear how all of the data was obtained and that the study system is properly described. Assure that the materials and methods are clear.Make sure the reasons for performing the study are clear and consistent with the rest of the manuscript. While the abstract offers the reader a concise understanding of the study at hand, the introduction should also include information about the larger research question that prompted the study. Differentiate between the introduction and the abstract.Abstracts act as the teaser for any paper so they should be succinct and captivating, sharing the key aspects of a study and able to stand on their own and be comprehensible to someone outside the field. Editors often depend on peer reviewers as experts in a specific scientific field to give a paper context within the wider scope of the discipline and this overview will help establish the paper’s main messages and key takeaways.Īfter reading through a manuscript once and writing a summary, dive back in and take note of key details that will lead to manuscript discoverability- title, abstract and keywords.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |